Home  ›  Shehita

Shehita

Shehita
Shehita
Shehita, Germany eighteenth century (illustration from Paul Christian Kirchner, Jdisches Ceremonial - Beschreibung und Gebrauch Jdischer Feste, 1734)
Sources halakhic
Texts in Jewish law relating to this article
Bible Deuteronomy 12:20-21
Babylonian Talmud Treaty Houllin
Sefer Hamitzvot asse No. 146
Sefer HaHinoukh mitzvah No. 451
Mishna Torah Sefer kodashim, Hilkhot shehita
Shulchan Aruch Yore Dea chap. 1-27
change Consult the documentation of the model

The shehita ( Hebrew : "slain") is the Jewish ritual slaughter by curbing The shehita in Jewish sources

The prescription of slaughter according to rules established is deduced from Deuteronomy 12:20-21 ("When you say ..." I would eat meat "... you can kill of your herd or flock ... as I 've specified), although no details are contained on this "so that I have prescribed." The Torah states, however, various laws on how to handle carcasses: only animals that the Torah describes as "pure" and "no defects" may be slaughtered and eaten , the flesh of the animal must be emptied of its blood and it must be covered , blood, tallow and entrails of animals are prohibited and it is forbidden to slaughter an animal and its offspring on the same day . Furthermore, in memory of the patriarch Jacob, suffered a hip injury during his fight with the angel on the shores of Jabbok the children of Israel do not eat the "sinew of the hip (sciatic nerve) which must be removed after slaughter.

The corpus of the laws of shehita has been mainly oral before being reduced to writing in various compilations Tannaitic , the Mishna and the Sifre , midrash to learn the laws of the Book of Numbers and Deuteronomy. According to this, one can infer: "You can kill it is a single ritual slaughter, and that its goal is holy (the presentation of offerings ) or secular (the consumption of meat ); " the way I've specified "means that" Moses received on Mount Sinai with the laws of the esophagus, trachea, much of one for poultry, the greater part of two The cattle " .

These laws are covered and detailed in the Treaty Houllin. It teaches that every Jew can practice shehita, with the exception of a child, an idiot or a deaf mute (the medieval authorities and later will be more restrictive on this point). The course of the shehita is summarized by the rabbis as five basic laws, all orally transmitted to Moses . According to one view, shehita would apply only to livestock and animals (that is to say non-domestic animals) and what are the sages who would later extended to poultry and it is in any case not necessary for fish and insects allowed . It may not in any case take place only healthy animals and is invalid if the verification post-slaughter revealed the presence of an injury or illness which caused the death of the animal in the year . It is not required for a beast found in the womb after slaughter, provided that it "has not set foot on the ground" (which is immediately seen as part of its mother and not as an independent being) .

Discussed many times, these laws are codified in the twelfth century by Moses Maimonides in his Mishneh Torah. It is on this that are based authors of the Arbaa Tourime and Shulchan Aruch , which include laws shehita in the first part of Section Yore Dea.

Ritual shehita

Shehita Illustration XV century

The shohet

The shohet an individual must be highly qualified, whose mastery of the laws of shehita treifot and is evidenced by a certificate (Kabbalah) issued by a competent rabbinic authority before which he made three shehitot

.
In addition to limitations contained in the Talmud, the shohet not exercise if his hands are shaking or intoxicated , and later medieval authorities restrict access to the profession to women and that Jews who transgress voluntarily .

The knife killing

The shehita can be made with a particular knife, called hallaf or Sakin. It must meet certain requirements in terms of the size, sharpness, texture, etc.. and be capable of being refined and polished with the sharpness and finesse required for shehita.

Unlike animals for slaughter, a priori presumed lawful, the blade is presumed hallaf flawed and should be checked, according to the Talmud before each bleeding . The Shulchan Aruch wanted to abolish this practice, considering the precaution unnecessary since any shohet is obviously learned in the laws of shehita, unlike the time of the Talmud . However, it has continued to the present day.

The knife to slaughter has been a serious controversy between Hasidim and Mitnagdim the eighteenth century: the Hasidim wanted to introduce a new method of preparation of the knife, rejected by the Gaon of Vilna. It enacted a herem (anathema) on shehita and meat from Hasidim in 1772. The ban was later lifted Slaughter

After checking his knife and before slaughter, shohet recites the blessing on the slaughter (Blessed are you ... Who hast sanctified by Thy commandments and hast commanded us to slaughter). In the case where many animals must be slaughtered, one blessing suffices. After the blessing, all conversation not related to the slaughter is prohibited .

The act of slaughter itself is to cut the esophagus and trachea of the animal. Both pipes should be resolved among beasts and cattle, only one in birds. The slaughter is legal if they are almost totally and not totally cut . The shohet applies his knife after the stretched skin incision for a free and easy. The shehita occurs downstream of the larynx, upstream of the bifurcation of the trachea . The incision is in the middle of the neck and includes only the soft parts (the cervical vertebrae should not be affected). The vessels are to be drilled on both sides of the neck in poultry .

The shehita guided by five fundamental principles taught by the rabbis as the errors to avoid:

  • shehiya (, "delay"): there can be no interruption during the slaughter knife to make a back and forth until the bodies are sliced ;
  • derassa (, "pressure") during this movement back and forth, the knife should be laid gently across the throat, without pressure from the shohet, including pressing the finger on the blade ;
  • 'Halada (, "Landfill"): the blade of the knife should be placed on the throat and be visible in its entirety during the shehita ;
  • hagrama ( "slip") the limits within which the knife will be inserted in the large ring of the trachea at the top of the upper lobe of the lungs when inflated, it is prohibited to carry out the curbing of this framework or exceed it ;
  • 'Ikkour ( "pull") or the trachea or esophagus (or vessels) can not be torn or dislocated during the shehita .

The breach of any of these five rules gives the slaughtered animal status Nevel, except for 'ikkour as eggs and milk from animals such supplies remain well that the beast does more.

Suites slaughter

Shehita, Germany eighteenth century. Illustration: Paul Christian Kirchner: "Ceremonial Jdisches, 1734

As soon as the shehita completed, the shohet must still carry out some steps necessary for the Kosher meat, although it is more than shehita per se.

Bedikot

The shohet must:

  • the bedikat simanim ( Hebrew : "verification" signs ", that is to say the esophagus and trachea) to ensure that it has achieved shehita properly, without violating any of the five above rules , which would make the beast a nevele (carrion).
  • the bedikat treifot ( Hebrew : ), verification of eighteen defects commonly encountered in making the beast Treif ("torn"). As the beasts and cattle for slaughter must be no external fault and are considered safe by default, only the lungs are actually checked to find blood clots or perforation
. This measure of severity gave its name to the Glatt Kosher , more rigorous than usual.

Historically, bedikot were performed by the shohet who had carried out the slaughter. Currently, they are left to care for a mashguiah ("supervisor") of the kashrut , which shall then make the hekhsher (certificate of kashrut) on the products to the consumer. A rabbi is also the scene of slaughter when in doubt Nikkour

The nikkour involves removing parts of the animal forbidden for consumption, after the checks were made. It is certain organs such as kidneys and intestines, blood vessels (in view of the prohibition of eating blood), and sciatic nerve, for cattle, tallow (helev) .

The procedure is long and tedious, especially the posterior part of the animal. Learning is difficult and unrewarding (acquiring meat often unappetizing appearance), the practice of the posterior nikkour (nikkour ahoram) has gradually lost in most communities, so that the posterior part of the The animal is often sold on the market non-Jewish , .

Other

In the case of birds and non-domestic animals, the shohet must cover the bloodshed during the shehita with dirt or ash , after reciting the appropriate blessing . At the time of the Temple, he had also taken the parties back to Cohen , namely the shoulder, jaw and stomach .

Social aspects shehita

The shehita is one of the pillars of traditional Jewish societies (number of Ashkenazi surnames as Schchter, Schechter, Reznik, etc.. Thereof) alone to ensure their compliance with red meats and white standards of the Act Jewish. From the twelfth century, some Spanish communities levied a tax to fund the voluntary and shohet shehita; this usage then spread in Eastern Europe , ). It is subject to strict controls by the Rabbinical organizations, which are involved both in training of fellers in the good performance of the slaughter. In Israel , the shehita is supervised by the Chief Rabbinate in the service of the state, the glatt kosher is controlled by several private ultra-Orthodox Legal aspects and controversies around the shehita

The shehita was perceived, especially from the nineteenth century, when a large portion of Jews in Western Europe have entered into the urban fabric, as a method of cruel killing in violation of the rights of animals. She is currently attracting, with other forms of ritual slaughter, many debates around the world, outside of the state of Israel

The Jewish authorities deny any such claims (according to traditional Jewish sources, the shehita must conform to the respect and the absence of cruelty to animals , , a major principle of Judaism ) and insist that the basic tenets of shehita designed to provide the animal a quick death without suffering (as well as several studies have shown , , , ).
However, other surveys and studies argue that these principles are not always implemented or will implement in practice , and France, a study conducted by INRA in 2009 concludes that " effectiveness of the ritual slaughter in terms of induction of unconsciousness is dependent on both technical aspects, equipment and priest (sic), and aspects of animal ", she suggests" to apply a stunning after the ritual slaughter " .

In Europe

The first votes in favor of abolishing the shehita were heard in 1864. They encounter no echo outside the kingdom of Saxony and Switzerland in 1866. However, investigations are conducted, particularly in Tsarist Russia in 1876, the doctor's report concludes Isaac Dembo Aleksandrovich the invalidity of the criticism against the shehita . The Veterinary College of Sweden did the same in 1920. The first bill to abolish the shehita is deposited in the German parliament in 1887 (it was unanimously rejected) . Norway votes to ban shehita its territory in 1930. She is also a measure in Germany in 1933 (that order is set aside in 1960), as Hitler came to power, then Sweden and Iceland. For many Jews, the Semitic character of these historic steps no doubt .

The shehita does not comply with European standards for slaughter adopted in 1979 by the Council of Europe : they include a stunning pre-mortem in the compulsory slaughter protocol , which makes the animal Taref the eyes of Jewish law, whatever the method used . The project DIALREL conducted in 2010 by the European Commission, based on studies conducted in New Zealand in 2009 inter alia, reaffirmed these positions, he concludes that such methods of curbing result in numerous animal suffering and it is clear , comparison between all methods of slaughter stunning pre-mortem seems the most able to mitigate . An amendment in the draft regulation on informing consumers about the quality of food was passed to that effect June 16, 2010 by the European Parliament , providing a labeling system indicating whether the animal was or was not slaughtered according to European standards . The Jewish authorities in England have noted the potentially discriminatory effect of this amendment on the shehita .

Currently, Directive 93/119/EEC which, while advocating the stunning pre-mortem, also includes a measure of exemption under the Freedom of worship is being applied in various EU countries European. In 2004:

  • of Sweden and outside the European Union, Norway , the Iceland and Switzerland (since the acceptance of a popular initiative in 1893 ) require the stunning pre-mortem, de facto banning ritual slaughter. They allow the importation of meat ritually slaughtered abroad at a higher price. Switzerland restricts this permission to the only Jewish community;
  • of Germany , the United Kingdom and the Netherlands have so far tolerated the practice. However, government advisory bodies including the Farm Animal Welfare Council and NGO's including Compassion in World Farming having spoken strongly against the ritual slaughter, this exemption is being questioned in England ;
  • in Denmark , in Finland and in certain provinces of Austria , the slaughter was followed by a post-slaughter stunning , , ;
  • in France and Belgium , ritual slaughter is authorized and regulated;
  • of Spain , the Ireland and Italy apply Directive 93/119/EEC, without public debate (Spain does, however, that the slaughter of sheep and cattle that forbidden) .

Outside Europe

Method of restraint and slaughter of animals proposed in 1996 by Temple Grandin

In the United States

The United States is one of the countries with legislation to protect ritual slaughter: freedom of worship is forbidden by the First Amendment and the Humane Slaughter Act (also in force in Canada) defines ritual slaughter as the one of the humane killing methods . However, stopping short of 1958 prohibits the animal be stunned before, which poses the same problems at shehita in Europe.

Temple Grandin , professor of animal science from the University of Colorado and an activist for the welfare of animals, has developed several techniques of restraint consistent with the Human Slaughter Act and in cooperation with the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards (legislative body Conservative Judaism ) . It voted in 2000 the adoption of methods of Grandin and the rejection of interference .

The monitoring body for the ritual slaughter performed by Orthodox Jewish ritual remains the Orthodox Union.
When the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals released in 2005 pictures of a slaughterhouse glatt kosher, which shows including cattle remain conscious for several minutes after being felled by the rules , processes that slaughterhouse are strongly criticized by the CJLS and Grandin (the latter would emphasize that the shehita proves generally superior to other methods of slaughter and that these are the methods of this slaughter - and he alone - who are the subject of his criticism ) but they are defended by the OU (which nevertheless insists that efforts be made in the direction of the PETA) .

Other

The New Zealand decided to ban shehita its territory , following studies conducted in 2009 which concluded that the technique of shehita not reduce animal pain . The conclusions of these studies were rejected by Temple Grandin because it believes the protocol used by the authors would not be that ritual slaughter .

References

  1. a , b , c , d , e , f , g and h in Chehitah S.-A. Goldberg (ed.), Encyclopedic Dictionary of Judaism , ed. Stag / Robert Laffont, collection Mouthpieces, Paris 1996, pp. 200-202
  2. Exodus 22:30; Leviticus 22:18-25, Deuteronomy 14:3-21
  3. Deuteronomy 12:23-24 & 27
  4. Leviticus 17:13-14
  5. Leviticus 3:17 & 7:25-27
  6. Leviticus 10:28 p.m.
  7. Genesis 32:25-33
  8. Sifre on Deuteronomy 12:21, quoted by Maimonides, Sefer Hamitzvot , positive mitzvah No. 146
  9. Houllin 1:1 & Houllin TB 13a-b
  10. TB Houllin 9b
  11. ibid. 27b-28a, from Numbers 11:22
  12. ibid. 43a
  13. ibid. 74a
  14. Glose of Rem "was on Shulchan Arukh Yore Dea 1:1
  15. Shulchan Arukh Yore Dea 1:5
  16. CAYD 1:8 & Rem gloss of "ad was. loc.
  17. Tosafot on Houllin 2a gloss on Hakol; Rema's gloss on CAYD 1:1
  18. CAYD 2:5
  19. Houllin TB 17b-18a
  20. CAYD 6:17 p.m.
  21. Houllin TB 86b, Shulchan Arukh Yore Dea 19
  22. Houllin TB 27a
  23. CAYD 20:1
  24. ibid. 20:3
  25. ibid. 9:22 p.m.
  26. ibid. 23
  27. ibid. 24:1-6
  28. ibid. 24:7-11
  29. ibid. 20 & 24:12-14
  30. ibid. 24:15-20
  31. TB Houllin 9a Shulchan Arukh Yore Dea 25
  32. CAYD 39; see a href = "# http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=494&letter=B 1509" class = "external text" rel = "nofollow"> ha-Bediat Reah on Jewish Encyclopedia
  33. (he) Maimonides, Mishneh Torah , Sefer Kedousha, 6:1 & 8:1 Maakhalot assourot
  34. (en) Porging on Jewish Encyclopedia
  35. a and b (in) R AZ Zivotofsky, " What's the Truth about Nikkur Achoraim? "on Kashrut.com
  36. cf. Leviticus 5:13 p.m.
  37. Houllin chap. 6; CAYD 28
  38. Houllin 10:1, cf. Deuteronomy 18:3
  39. halal or kosher meat, eat them without knowing
  40. (fr) Louis Ginzberg & Julius H. Greenstone, " Cruelty to Animals "on Jewish Encyclopedia
  41. The Jewish ritual slaughter, respect for animals
  42. cf. TB Baba Metzia 32b
  43. (en) A Guide to Shechita , May 2009
  44. Y Ruckebusch, 1977: Physiology, Pharmacology, Therapeutics Animales, Paris, Editions Maloine
  45. LUC Michel, 1983 Jewish Ritual Slaughter and Animal Welfare, PhD State Veterinarian, Lyon
  46. (en) W. Schulze, H. Schultze-Petzold, AS Hazem, and R. Gross, " Experiments For the objectification of pain and consciousness Dring Conventional (captive bolt stunning) and religiously Mandated (ritual cutting) procedures for slaughter sheep and calves , "Deutsche Wochenschrift Tieraerztliche (Weekly German veterinarian), 1978
  47. Fiszon Bruno, " The Jewish dietary laws (kashrut) "on Veterinary Academy of France, May 29, 2008
  48. a and b PETA's investigation of AgriProcessors
  49. Aaron Gross, When Kosher Is not Kosher , Tikkun Magazine , March / April 2005, Vol. 20, No. 2
  50. a and b Animal Pain: Expert Report on INRA , December 2009
  51. (en) Dembo, Isaak Aleksandrovich, 1847? -1906 The Jewish method of slaughter Compared with Other Methods: From The Humanitarian, hygienic, and Economic Points of View
  52. (he) Zerah Warhaftig , the historical controversy and legal action against the shehita on Daat
  53. Cf JJ Berman, The Canadian Jewish Chronicle - Aug 20, 1943. Clinical Study in Falsehood. The Fiftieth Anniversary of Prohibition was.
  54. European Convention For the Protection of Animals for Slaughter
  55. What's Wrong With stunning? on Chabad.org
  56. a and b MELLOR, DJ, GIBSON, TJ & Johnson, CB 2009. A re-evaluation of The Need to stun Prior to slaughter calves by ventral neck incision: An introductory review. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 57 (2), 74 -76
  57. page 20 VON Holleben K. et al. Report on good practices and opposing - Animal Welfare Concerns in relation to slaughter practices From the viewpoint of veterinary science, Deliverable 1.3; DIALREL program, February 2010
  58. European Parliament legislative resolution of 16 June 2010 on the proposal for a European Parliament and Council Directive on consumer information on food
  59. This ill-conceived amendment Against discrimination which kosher food on ShechitaUK.org, June 16, 2010
  60. Council Directive 93/119/EC of 22 December 1993 on the protection of animals at slaughter or killing in EUR-Lex
  61. See Halal and Kosher slaughter 'must end'
  62. Italian bioethics committee Report on Ritual Animal Slaughtering and Suffering (2003), Annex 3
  63. U.S. Commission Report on Animal Health in Austria
  64. Religious Right
  65. Cf F. Bergeaud-Blackler Emerging around the Muslim ritual slaughtering: a European perspective , 2004
  66. 7 USCA 1902. Humane methods
  67. Temple Grandin, "Recommended Ritual Slaughter Practices"
  68. "Shackling and Hoisting", The Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of The Conservative movement. The Rabbinical Assembly, New York, 2002
  69. "Statement of Dr. Temple Grandin, consultant to the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the American Meat Institute"
  70. "Statement Orthodox Union of Rabbis and Certifying Agencies on Recent Publicity is Kosher Slaughter"
  71. ShechitaUK Respond to decision by New Zealand Government on ShechitaUK.org, February 2010
  72. Temple Grandin, " Discussion of research That Shows That Kosher Halal Slaughter Without stunning gold causes bread "on grandin.com, February 2010

Source

Notes

Related articles

External Links

Bibliography

  • Chehitah in S.-A. Goldberg (ed.), Encyclopedic Dictionary of Judaism, ed. Stag / Robert Laffont, collection Mouthpieces, Paris 1996, pp. 200-202
Judaism and Jewish culture
Who is a Jew? The Jews Jewish Identity The term "Jew" Converting to Judaism
A life in Judaism Shema Israel Shabbat family purity Ethics kosher ritual purity
Principles of Faith YHWH Monotheism divine retribution Torah Mitzvot Eschatology Chosen People
Large text Tanakh Mishnah Talmud Midrash Mishna Torah Zohar Shulchan Aruch
Leaders of Judaism Patriarchs Matriarchs Moses Prophets Grand Assembly Binomials Tannaim Amoraim Savoram Geonim medieval authorities authorities and subsequent current
Worship Celebrations in Judaism Amida Sha'harit Mincha Maariv Musaf Synagogue Shtiebel Siddur Talit tefillin
Figures of Worship Rabbi judge hazzan Gabbai circumciser faller gravedigger
Streams of Judaism Orthodox Judaism conservative reformed Reconstructionist Karaite humanist
Jewish Culture Jewish languages Jewish Cuisine Jewish Music Jewish Education Jewish Humor Jewish Art Habits Jews
Jewish history
See also Criticism of Judaism Antisemitism Jewish political movements Israel


Leave a Reply

0 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 vote, average: 0.00 out of 51 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5 (0 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5, rated)
Loading ... Loading ...
Help us improve the wiki Send Your Comments