Home  ›  Legal

Legal

Sources of law
Science humaines.svg
( Category )
Custom
Doctrine
Jurisprudence
Law
PaletteDroitConstit.png
General Introduction
Constitutional law - Constitution
General theory
State Law - Sovereignty
Legal Standards
Constitution & Component
Law & Legislator
Rules & Executive
Political Systems
Parliamentary regime
Presidential system
Constitutional Justice
Supreme Court
Constitutional Court
Constitutional Council
Comparative Constitutional Law
All constitutions
Legal Portal Wiki
The Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen French, which always has a constitutional
First page of original edition ( 1804 ) of the Code Napoleon

By law , the law (from the Latin meaning is a legal rule supreme, general and impersonal, or ensemble of such rules. source of law , the law is now typically prescribed by Parliament , representative of the people and therefore holds the legislative power , the power to enact laws. Sometimes referred to as a synonym for law legislation although the legislation also includes regulations which also lays down general and impersonal, but the author is the executive branch.

The concept of law is defined in relation to a share contract and the treaty (which result from a negotiation between equals (in terms of law)), secondly in relation to other sources of law: tradition ( customs ), the case law , the fundamental laws ( Constitution , "Great Charter", etc..), and regulations and other written acts of executive power when the law is the work of the legislature , often embodied in a parliament representing the people. In countries that have kept the forms of direct democracy , the law may be passed by all citizens.

Summary

Overview

The law is included in the set of rules and standards in a given society. The law is often a generic term for all acts, wherever they are in the hierarchy of norms (standards constitutional , statutory or strict formal sense, regulatory ...)

In terms of its form, the law is a legal act taken by a specific authority, usually the Parliament, which is legitimate and has the capacity to command. In countries experiencing a form of separation of powers , the law is a standard legal adopted by the legislature in the forms and procedures prescribed by the constitutional law of the place. Its application can then be specified by an instrument made by the executive branch , such as an implementation decree in France or a Royal Decree in Belgium , and will also further clarified by the interpretation thereof by the courts.

Today, the law is the main source of law in countries of civil law tradition. Even in countries of common law , the law tends to take a particular weight. Even though they now tend to be confused, the notions of law and rule of law remain separate.

The rule of law is a tool available to the lawyer who allows him to work according to the ideal of justice. Any freedom or any right necessarily implies, to train fully, a duty of tolerance and respect , even responsibility.

The law is not necessarily a rule of law, since by definition it is not necessarily created for the purpose of ideal justice The law and the contract

"Agreements legally formed take the place of law for those who made them." (Article 1134 Civil Code Napoleon ", 1804 Hierarchy of standards
The Act, by Jean Feuchre

The legal system is organized, for all states, according to the theory of hierarchy of norms of Hans Kelsen. The lower standards and must be consistent with what is enacted by the higher standard.

Different hierarchical standards are:

There is no hierarchy between the laws, but they sometimes contradict themselves and you have to decide which applies. It appeals in these cases the general principles of law:

  • in criminal matters, the law that is kinder to the culprit that is applied,
  • we prefer the law that regulates a particular case specifically referred to the general law,
  • we prefer the law most recent prior law,
  • one must sometimes resort to legislative intent, based on various factors, including parliamentary debates or statements of Government

Rule Form

As for the Constitution , we must distinguish two aspects of the law:

  • The material dimension: this is what the law.
  • The formal dimension (or organic) that makes the law, and how.

A law must be made by an authority with the legislature , often called the legislature (even though it is a collective person, as a parliament ). It must also be made by following specific procedures and forms. Lately, it must meet the definition of a law, as defined by the legal system of the country.

When legislation is regularly taken in these conditions, only the legislature itself or a higher authority can undo or redo the (rule of thumb of "parallel forms"). When all conditions are not or are no longer together, we can decide (or not ...) it is not a "real" law and that another authority may override or modify.

Power law

This section does not cite any sources. Please add a note references verifiable or template {{}} reference desired .

The law enacted by a body, the legislature, which we recognize a particular authority, more or less. It is in this respect two main approaches:

  • law as an expression of the general will of the people , the general interest. In this conception, the law knows no limit other than that she may also ask, in particular the design is traditional in France. The law has a strong symbolic content, that of proclaiming the social ideal, but at the risk of neglecting the practical aspects and the real effects: no matter that the law does not work, provided it is "fair." When this aspect prevails, we get legislation containing generous farms or proclamations of principle, statutes of fact response to scandals or management of a collective emotion, all with a practical content (allow, prohibit, tax , subsidize, punish ...) reduced or no significant effect. The law-maker (usually the legislature, unless it fell under the sway of another political body, as one party or the Executive) dominates the political field.
  • law as limited to inter-individual fighting for dominance, as moral tool used to avoid the use of real weapons. In this conception, the law and the legislature have no authority at the height of their success to practice effectively organize a company quite suitable for the locals, that is to say limited authority and subject to Multiple moral conceptions of what things should be, higher principles are recognized, no law can violate without ipso facto cease to be a law. The law remains a very practical thing, but at the risk of cynicism and immorality: regardless of whether the law is not "fair" if it achieves its goals.

Parliament is an organ, important but not dominant, the political field.

These two contradictory conceptions of the foundations, but remain consistent in practice, when designing a law that conforms to the highest ideals (Human Rights, the "general principles of law", ...), which expresses how aspect she wants to be treated and which contains provisions for effective practices to get closer.

Scope of legislation

In unitary states , only the State has legislative power and can enact laws. Conversely, in the Federated States there are both federal laws and laws of federated entity. The Constitution generally accurate in this case what skills within the federal government and which belong to entities. The texts of the legislative can have different names depending on whether they are adopted at the federal or state level, as in Belgium where the laws passed at the federal level and decrees in communities or regions have the same level in the hierarchy. Constitutions can also specify the scope of the law and the regulation.

Legislative Process

Main article: legislative procedure.

The legislative process usually includes three major phases:

Between adoption and enforcement or enactment may involve a constitutional review (optional or mandatory depending on the circumstances). This control can also act retroactively on appeal when the law is applied.

Name

The laws are generally referred to by their date or purpose (social modernization law, law of separation of church and state). For the sake demagogic or simply mnemonics, laws are sometimes referred to by the name of a promoter, minister or parliamentary (Perben law, Sapin law, law Gouvion Saint-Cyr, Mahoux law, etc..), Sometimes even by their date ( Act 1901), or finally by their rank in the parliamentary session, (Bill 101, Bill C-36).

By law, only the exact title are allowed. In a pinch, we can accept the titles truncated or a simple date. The use of a name of minister, the instigator of the law, does not reflect the constitutional text, as the initiative of the law belongs to the Government or Parliament, never to a single minister. It is nevertheless admitted to state as follows: 1995 Law on spatial planning (law called "Chevenement).

Depending on the country

In Belgium

Bill is a government initiative and must be submitted to the State Council , which has a period of one month before giving an opinion, while a bill is a private member.

The resolutions adopted at the regional and community level ( Flemish Region , Walloon Region , Flemish Community , French Community , speaking Community called "decrees" (regional or community) and have the same binding force as law (ordinances of the Brussels region Capital has a slightly separate status). The rules of adoption are the same as for the law, mutatis mutandis.

The law was passed by the House of Representatives of Belgium and sometimes by the Belgian Senate. It is usually developed as follows:

  • a project is developed by the federal government. Alternatively, the federal Parliament can itself be the initiator of the text, then called "bill".
  • the text becomes "Bill" when it is approved by the House of Representatives or the Senate.
  • Once approved by the House and the Senate, it is subject to Royal Assent.
  • unless the law itself determines the date of entry into force, it becomes effective 10 days after publication in the Moniteur belge.

All laws are not necessarily passed simultaneously by the House and Senate. The phenomenon of shuttle that previously existed (and still exists in France) and that slowed the legislative process has been greatly reduced.

For example, the budget and Naturalization (formal laws) are passed by the House alone, the budget vote is the ultimate symbol of legislative control over the executive.

But the revision of the Constitution and consent to treaties must still be passed by both Houses. In addition, 15 senators (or more) may require that a proposal or a bill is passed by Senate: in this case, the same text must be passed by both chambers. In addition, certain laws must be passed to special majorities.

France

Types of law

This section is empty, insufficiently detailed or incomplete. Your help is welcome!
Common Laws

Constitutional review non-mandatory, section 61 paragraph 2. They aim to establish a policy or economic or social.

Organic Laws

These laws are adopted pursuant to the Constitution (the Constitution directs that steps be taken by law). Constitutional review mandatory.

They set the rules for the organization of government and are subject to a specific procedure laid down in Articles 46 and 61 of the Constitution.

Other cases
  • Constitutional laws: this category, as enacted by the doctrine is not recognized by the Constitutional Council are revisions of the Constitution.
  • The orders : heirs of decrees of the Third Republic , they may have the force of law if:
    • the ordinance is approved by law;
    • its provisions are contained in a law through a legislative rider.

The Initiative

A bill is a government initiative. It must be submitted to the State Council , which has a period of one month before rendering an advisory opinion.

A bill is a private member (less than 10% of laws passed), since the constitutional reform of 23 July 2008 and may optionally be transmitted to the State Council for review.

Adoption

Parliamentary Acts

The journey of a project or a bill begins in the Office of one of two meetings to decide what day he or she will be debated by this Assembly. The agenda itself is determined by the Government ( rationalized parliamentarism ). Then it is given to one of eight committees that make reports and proposals on the text. With the constitutional law of 23 July 2008 , Parliament should now set its own agenda, however, with the possibility for the government to give priority to certain texts.

During his parliamentary discussion, the text can be modified by amendments tabled by the parliamentary assemblies of each. The text thus makes the "shuttle" between the two assemblies to reach agreement on the substance and form of legislation. The National Assembly has the last word in the absence of consensus (after a meeting of a joint commission composed of seven senators and the same number of members) or if the government wants (except in matters affecting the organization the Senate ).

When the text is finally adopted, the President of the Republic has fifteen days to enact. If deemed necessary, the President of the Republic may request the Constitutional Council's opinion on the constitutionality of the law before its promulgation. The promulgation of the law authenticates and makes enforceable. It is then published in the Official Gazette of the French Republic (Edition Laws and decrees).

Referendum Laws

A referendum law is a law enacted after a referendum, which is an example of direct democracy


With the referendum , the parliament is no longer the only national representation. The National expressed willingness to face the parliament by a direct link between the people and the executive. Some think it is a plebiscite where distrust of a referendum. The referendum is still framed by the Constitutional Council in terms of section 60 of the Constitution. There are several types of referendums: Article 89 (for revisions), Article 11 (for the organization of power), the Article 53 al. 3 (for the territorial integrity) and Article 88-5 (for accession to the EU).

When we talk of referendum legislation, it speaks to those taken by the procedure of Article 11. This is a shared power between the President and the Prime Minister, that is to say that the signature of both is required. Under Article 11, the referendum shall be only on "the organization of government, reforms relating to economic policy, social or environmental nation and public services contributing thereto, or tending to authorization to ratify a treaty which, without being unconstitutional, would affect the functioning of institutions. "

But since the Constitution Act of 2008, the initiative of the referendum may also result from a minority of MPs since the third paragraph of Article 11 provides: "A referendum on the first paragraph Control of the constitutionality of the law

The constitutional review of laws in France is a priori (before its entry into force) and following the constitutional revision of 23 July 2008, a subsequent verification is possible. This control is performed by a specialized body: the Constitutional Council. The Constitutional Council rules on the constitutionality of the law before it, concerning the challenged provisions, but also about anything it considers to raise office. The opinion makes it binding on all authorities: the President of the Republic, who will not enact a law unconstitutional, the government and the courts, which must take into account the reservations of compliance set by the board in their implementing acts (decrees, circulars) and decisions.

However, are not subject to the laws that control where the Constitutional Council was seized, either by the President of the Republic or the Prime Minister or by one of two Presidents of the Houses of Parliament or by seventy deputies or senators. If the board has not been entered, the constitutional review is not a priori, and do not be after. This is particularly the case with all laws predating the creation of the council by the Constitution of the Fifth Republic, dated October 4, 1958.

In this case, a law may be unconstitutional in effect. This is the theory of law-screen. Unconstitutional legal provisions apply even if the result of actions (administrative or judicial) themselves unconstitutional: it is said that the law "a screen" between the act and the Constitution.

In practice, it is rare for several reasons. The constitution rule especially the organization of the state, a matter which is fairly subject to constitutional challenge, the organic laws which specify the details of this have often been subjected to constitutional review. The constitution also contains some broad principles in its preamble, but they are fairly shared and old enough so that it is rare that laws, even old ones, are in contradiction with them. Moreover, international treaties can take these principles and, while judges may not refer to the constitution, they can ensure the conformity of an act to a treaty. Finally, a legal provision may have given different interpretations practices, and wherever possible we must give an interpretation consistent with the constitution.

Crisis of Law in France

Main article: Legal certainty.

French law is in crisis according to many lawyers , including in particular the President of the Constitutional Council : Pierre Mazeaud , it expresses its wishes for the year 2005 .

The main ailments afflicting the law are:

  • Multiple Acts

These legislative inflation rampant that we know today. This is probably the worst of all evils. Parliament passed many laws for reasons many and varied. The problem is that the members here are not all lawyers. Are too often adopted measures poorly written, incomprehensible or unworkable.

  • Disposable laws

Policies seeking to register their names in the marble of the law, they rush to pass a. Then we see that the law was poorly written. It remains only to throw it (in most cases it remains unimplemented).

  • Laws emotional

It is a strong trend. It is the desire to legislate whenever an issue arises, even before the causes of the problem are known. Once past the emotion, if the law was passed, we often find, again, that decision in an emergency, it was poorly written.

  • Soft laws

Also called neutron legislation. " It is a law without mandatory content, which will therefore have no practical effect. Problems related to laws and disposable emotional.

  • Protectionist laws

These are laws designed to protect companies by keeping them from competition or the inevitable evolution of science and technology. This is the case law DADVSI and HADOPI that can be likened to the famous Act Locomotive English.

United Kingdom

The law differs from the law (law) since it emanates from Parliament (statute law). Although it was found in 1610 that the judge was not to enforce a law contrary to reason , it is now accepted that "the opposite of American legislator whose laws are subject to constitutional review, the British parliament sees recognize its sovereignty limited by any provision / Sup> ". "From the standpoint of constitutional law, what would be prescribed by the parliament will have the force of law Quotes

The stone of King Hammurabi shows the god Shamash revealing a code of laws to the king.
"The law allows or she defends, she directs, establishes, or punishes it rewards it." Portalis
Nemo censetur legem ignorare (is no excuse to ignore the law)

Adage (not legal) that does not mean that one must know all the laws, but that one can not plead ignorance of the law to evade the law.

"The law must have authority over men, not men on the law. . Pausanias
"Cedant arma toga (What arms yield to the toga). Cicero

Consular executive power (potestas) is orders of authority (auctoritas) Senate authors of the laws. Thus, the executive president is guided and bounded by the joint legislative authority of Congress and the Senate of the United States of America.

The Romans had a saying: Dura lex sed lex (The law is hard but it's the law) The law should apply, if we find it too hard (or, more generally, inappropriate), it should change rather than evade it.

"It is sometimes necessary to change some laws, but the case is rare, and when it happens, it should touch it with a trembling hand." Montesquieu
"A thing is not just because it is law, but it must be law because it is right. . Montesquieu
Life, liberty and property do not exist because men have made laws. Instead, it is because life, liberty and property existed as men have made laws. ( Frederic Bastiat ).
The law is a spider's web: the drone it wends its way, it entangles the fly.

Russian version of a proverb with its equivalent almost everywhere

Nothing that the law, all for her. Carr de Malberg , evoking the tradition legicentrist France.
Leges Plurimae pessima respublica. (More numerous the laws are, the worse the state).

Roman adage

"A law can never force a man to love me but it is important that it prevents him from lynching me."

Martin Luther King

See also

Related articles

External Links

Congo - Kinshasa
  • Leganet.cd , archive laws of the Democratic Republic of Congo
France

Bibliography

Act Bertrand Mathieu. Edition: Dalloz (2nd edition) The Act of Jean-Claude Becane Michel Couderc, Jean-Louis Herin.Editions Dalloz.2010. (2 nd edition)

References

  1. still in force in France
  2. Wishes for 2005
  3. Dr. Bonham's Case, 8 Rep.. 114
  4. JA Jolowicz, Prcis Dalloz English Law, 2nd ed., 1992, No. 48
  5. op.cit. ibid.
Political Philosophy
Basic Concepts Citizenship Constitution Right State Government Sovereignty Political Theories Justice Law Political Freedom Policy Power Political System international system
Domains Political Science International Relations Theory Theories of Social Contract


Leave a Reply

0 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 vote, average: 0.00 out of 51 vote, average: 0.00 out of 50 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5 (0 votes, average: 0.00 out of 5, rated)
Loading ... Loading ...
Help us improve the wiki Send Your Comments